Following numerous recent chemical exposure incidents at public pool venues (see accompanying article in this issue as well as the June 15 issue of Service Industry News), local news channels have been asking experts advice on how to protect the public.
A CBS news channel went to the West Cobb Aquatic Center in Powder Springs, Georgia, to ask for tips on how parents can make sure pools are safe to swim in.
They were told that vigilant staff water testing and recording, and even parents testing the water, can alleviate some of the concern.
An NBC news channel asking the advice of a pool care technician was told that parents should look for signs outside the lifeguard office for daily chemical levels.
“Anytime you walk into a pool deck, look for that sign…And when you see that sign and look at that, you know you’re in wellmonitored safe swimming water,” said a pool maintenance technician.
But even the most vigorous of testing protocols cannot protect against an unexpected surge of chlorine gas when an electrical interlock between the pool water circulation pump and the chemical feed system is lacking, improperly installed, or simply fails.
According to a Pool and Hot Tub Alliance Fact Sheet: When all is functioning correctly behind the scenes at pools with automated chemical control systems, chlorine-based disinfectant and acid are injected into a stream of water being pumped into the pool following a run through the filter. If the pool water circulation pump stops due to an unforeseen problem or for maintenance, and the chemical feed equipment continues to add chlorine-based disinfectant and acid into the line, the two chemicals may react to form hazardous chlorine gas. Chlorine gas produced this way displaces pool water in the line, with the amount being proportional to the length of time the circulation pump is out of service and the chemical feeders are operating.
When the pool water circulation pump is restarted and proper water circulation is restored, the chlorine gas is pushed through the line into the pool area where swimmers and staff may be exposed to hazardous levels. This scenario repeats itself several times each year in various locations, which prompted the American Chemistry Council and a group of public health and swimming pool industry representatives to develop a free YouTube training video to help prevent these unfortunate events. Their fact sheet is based on information and guidance offered in the video.
LEVELS OF ELECTRICAL INTERLOCK PROTECTION
Electrical interlock protection ensures that if the pool pump is disabled or loses prime/no flow situation, or there is any other loss or reduction of flow in the circulation system, the chemical feed equipment will also be disabled, avoiding the production of chlorine gas in the line. This shall be accomplished through an electrical interlock consisting of at least two of the following: 1. Circuit Breaker Design (Basic): Ensure the circulation pump and the chemical feed equipment are on the same electrical circuit. If the circuit powering the pump is tripped, power to the chemical feeders is also lost and there will be no injection of chemicals.
2. Pump or Filter Control. This method uses a basic three-way pump control panel with an AUTO/ OFF/HAND configuration. Ensure the chemical feed equipment is connected to only the AUTO function for pump control. The pump should be backwashed only in HAND mode. If the switch is in the OFF or HAND mode, power to the chemical feeders is also lost and there will be no injection of chemicals. For systems using regenerative filtration or sand filtration with automatic backwash control, there are common relays that can be programmed to disable chemical automation during bump or backwash sequences. Most variablespeed drives can be programmed to enable or disable automated chemical controllers. Never connect chemical feed systems directly to power, or “hot,” which bypasses the pump electrical interlock.
3. Float or Centrifugal Flow Switch. A float or centrifugal flow switch can be incorporated into the sample stream of the chemical controller, which samples water flow. When the sample stream loses flow, the switch signals the controller to stop the chemical feed.
4. Flow Switch or Electronic Flow Meter. A flow switch or electronic flow meter with signaling capabilities can be used in the main circulation system’s return stream of water, indicating there is flow through the main system.
• A flow switch could fail and send a false indication of water flow when there is none.
• The flow switch should only be used as a backup to the electrical interlock between the water circulation pump and chemical feed system.
• The safety switch system should be installed and maintained according to the manufacturer’s instructions and not modified or bypassed in any way.
• Conduct an initial challenge test upon installing an interlock system.
• Conduct monthly challenge tests, including a backwash cycle at least once per month, to ensure the proper operation of the interlock safety switch, sensors, and alarms.
• Basic interlock designs only react to electrical incidents, such as loss of power, and not to an inherent loss of water flow, which could be caused by something other than the loss of power.
• Basic protection can be lost if someone unknowingly unplugs the chemical feeder from the controlled circuit and plugs it into another circuit.
• An alarm should be activated whenever the chemical feeder is disabled through the interlock system to alert staff to evacuate the pool.
• Maintain proper labeling of all system components.
• Keep all signs, labels, and placards up to date and legible.
• Use safety signs as reminders to take action under certain circumstances.
• Follow OSHA h a z a r d communication plan requirements, including developing an emergency action plan.
POOLSTAFF BEST PRACTICES
1. The aquatic venue should be closed and all bathers removed from the pool and deck whenever maintenance work is to be performed on the circulation and chemical systems.
2. The pool and deck area should be cleared immediately when:
• A flow sensor detects no flow in the system.
• An unexpected or manual deactivation of the circulation pump occurs.
• The interlock system is activated, indicating a problem with the flow system.
3. Bathers should not be allowed back into the aquatic venue until the cause of the interruption is understood and the condition is corrected.
• The system should operate correctly for at least 5 minutes before bathers return to the water.
• Water should be tested for proper pH and free chlorine levels before bathers return to the water.
• Train staff to recognize highrisk scenarios that could lead to chlorine gas exposure, such as when water circulation ceases and when the electrical interlock and safety switch failure alert system is activated.
Each year dozens of visitors to aquatic facilities are accidentally exposed to unintentionally produced chlorine gas. These exposures result from a failure of the electrical interlock between the chemical feed equipment (usually involving acid and sodium hypochlorite bleach) and the water circulation pump. This video presents steps that aquatic staff can take to reduce the risk of these exposures.