logo
    • News
    • Classifieds
    • Free Subscription
    • Book Store
    • Submit
      • Submit a Classified Ad
      • Submit an Educational Announcement
      • Submit a letter to The Editor
    • Past Issues
    • Regional Trade Shows
    • Testimonials
    • Contact
    • News
    • Classifieds
    • Free Subscription
    • Book Store
    • Submit
      • Submit a Classified Ad
      • Submit an Educational Announcement
      • Submit a letter to The Editor
    • Past Issues
    • Regional Trade Shows
    • Testimonials
    • Contact
News
July 14, 2022
Liability waiver upheld against woman injured at Illinois fitness club

This June, an Illinois District court ruled in favor of Life Time Fitness regarding a lawsuit involving an injury sustained by a woman while walking on a swimming pool grate cover.

Trisha Heidrich, a Life Time Fitness member, claims that she was injured as she was exiting the gym’s swimming pool. Specifically, according to court documents, “while exiting the zerodepth swimming pool the pool filter/ grate cover broke, causing plaintiff's foot to fall through, get stuck and Plaintiff was caused to fall, striking the floor with great force and violence and sustaining serious and permanent injury.”

Through its negligence in maintaining and inspecting the pool grate to ensure that it was safe for patron use, the suit argues, Heidrich sustained a serious injury that is not normally associated with swimming or use of a pool.

In a rare decision, however, the court disagreed, stating that the gym’s “Assumption of Risk” and “Waiver of Liability” agreements protect the gym from the suit in question.

According to Attorney Deedee Gasch, who is not connected to the lawsuit, “generally, releases and waivers are not favored by courts and will be strictly construed against the party seeking to enforce them.”

This case was an exception. In his decision, United States Magistrate Judge M. David Weisman argued that falling while exiting a pool is within the scope of dangers that normally accompany using a pool. In its member usage agreement, Life Time Fitness expressly defined falling as a risk associated with using the gym. Heidrich’s case stated that Life Time Fitness “carelessly and improperly failed to properly maintain [and] inspect the swimming pool and specifically the pool filter/grate cover… to maintain an adequate maintenance program to ensure that the swimming pool and specifically the pool filter/grate cover was safe for patron use… used an inferior material for the pool filter/grate cover… and failed to warn members of the unsafe conditions.”

However, Judge Weisman found that the gym’s “Waiver of Liability” does in fact release Life Time from claims arising from any negligence of Life Time, including “negligent design, construction. repair, maintenance, operation”; “negligent failure to warn of or remove a hazardous, unsafe, dangerous or defective condition” and; “negligent failure to provide or keep premises in a reasonably safe condition.”

Weisman’s decision was unusual because, although every state is different, many states don’t support liability releases, with courts stating that upholding liability waivers is not in the public interest.

For example, disclaimers are entirely void in Virginia, Montana, and Louisiana, and their use is restricted in Arizona, New Mexico, and West Virginia.

The suit took place in Illinois, however, where, for Judge Weisman, it all came down to the language of the contract and the foresight of Life Time Fitness to anticipate the types of injuries and means of incurring those injuries while exercising on their premises.

LATEST NEWS
Idaho ends state mandated pool inspections
News
Idaho ends state mandated pool inspections
New law takes health safety regulatory power away from Idaho Dept. of Health
May 14, 2025
By Marcelle Dibrell Starting July 1, 2025, public swimming pools across Idaho will no longer be subject to state-mandated health inspections, the resu...
this is a test
Service starts with water sanitation
News
Service starts with water sanitation
May 14, 2025
Maintaining proper disinfection levels is the core of pool and spa maintenance. And while a pool and spa pump is often described as the heart of the p...
this is a test
News
Drowning prevention bills failed in Florida
May 14, 2025
A pair of Florida bills that would have tightened anti-drowning measures for the state’s residential pools failed in subcommittee meetings this April....
this is a test
Olympian gets 10 replacement medals
News
Olympian gets 10 replacement medals
May 14, 2025
Olympic swimmer Gary Hall Jr. lost all of his medals in the 2025 Los Angeles fires. When the house he was renting in the Pacific Palisades went up in ...
this is a test
News
Nominate the next PHTA superstar
May 14, 2025
The Pool & Hot Tub Alliance wants your help recognizing the best of the best in our industry. Do you know someone who goes above and beyond — on the j...
this is a test
News
United Chemical launches bromate study
May 14, 2025
United Chemical, a premier provider of specialty pool chemicals, is launching a new study that will examine a possible byproduct that may result from ...
this is a test
Read Our Newsletter
ePaper
coogle_play
app_store
Free Subscription
View Current Print Ads
Educational Announcements
Aquatic Training Institute

Educational Leverage

Foundation For Pool Industry Education

Locey Pool

Pool Chemistry Training Institute

Pool & Hot Tub Alliance

Portofino University

Underwater Pool Masters
Trade Show Dates
  • The International Pool Spa Patio Expo
    Nov. 12-14, Dallas, Texas
  • The Pool and Spa Show
    Jan. 28-30, Atlantic City, New Jersey
  • 35th Annual National Plasterers Conference
    Feb. 26-28, Lake Buena Vista, Florida
  • The Southwest Pool and Spa Show
    Feb. 4-8, Houston, Texas
  • The Western Pool and Spa Show
    Feb. 6-8, Long Beach, California
Books to Order
About Us Terms of Use Privacy Policy
We use cookies to ensure that our website gives you the best experience possible. By continuing to use this website, you agree to this use of cookies.OK