Carnival faces Legionnaires’ disease trial
News
November 14, 2026
Carnival faces Legionnaires’ disease trial
Failed mediation propels passenger lawsuit over water contamination toward 2027 court date

By Marcelle Dibrell

A lawsuit over a Legionnaires’ disease infection allegedly contracted aboard a Carnival cruise ship has developed into a major negligence dispute, with a possible trial set for April 2027.

Carnival Cruise Line passenger Steven Luther filed suit against the company on Sept. 12, 2025, alleging that he contracted Legionnaires’ Disease after using the tidal pool and whirlpools aboard the Mardi Gras during a six-night cruise from Port Canaveral, Florida. The voyage departed May 18, 2025.

After settlement negotiations failed in September 2026, Carnival Corporation and passenger Steven Luther are preparing for trial. In October, the court reopened the proceedings, established a new schedule, and referred the parties to mediation for another attempt at settlement.

According to the complaint, Luther’s illness required hospitalization at Cape Canaveral Hospital, where he received intravenous antibiotics and respiratory support. He alleges that he continues to experience respiratory problems and other lasting effects. The lawsuit accuses Carnival of negligence in maintaining, inspecting, and disinfecting the facilities; monitoring water quality and disinfectant levels; maintaining filtration systems; and warning passengers of potential exposure.

The complaint argues that Carnival knew, or should have known, about the risks associated with contaminated spa systems but failed to take appropriate precautions. It cites a 2006 report commissioned by Carnival that allegedly identified biofilm and oils in spa piping as factors contributing to Legionella growth. These remain allegations; the court has not found that Legionella was present in the ship’s water or that Carnival caused Luther’s illness.

Discovery has included depositions of Luther and his wife, Carnival’s corporate representative, medical witnesses, and other individuals. The parties also reported inspecting the Mardi Gras on May 2, 2026, and working to arrange a deposition of the ship’s onboard physician.

In a significant discovery ruling, the court ordered Carnival to produce medical records from between Feb. 1 and May 31, 2025, for passengers who reported symptoms commonly associated with Legionnaires’Disease, such as cough, fever, headaches, muscle aches, or shortness of breath.

A Sept. 30 expert disclosure provides the first public indication of what the records contain.

Dr. Omowunmi Osinubi, an occupational and environmental medicine specialist retained by Luther, is expected to testify that onboard records “demonstrate numerous passenger patient encounters with symptomology consistent with Legionella exposure.” She will also testify that “Legionella exposure cannot be epidemiologically ruled out during the relevant time period.” The disclosure does not identify any other passengers as having been diagnosed with Legionnaires’ Disease or tested positive for Legionella.

The disclosure identifies three experts expected to testify for Luther. Their opinions address the source and severity of his infection as well as the operation and maintenance of the ship’s recreational water facilities.

Dr. Alison Osinski, an aquatics and pool and spa operations expert, is expected to examine Carnival’s inspection practices, water chemistry, chemical treatment, and maintenance of the ship’s pools and spas. Her testimony will address alleged deficiencies in water treatment, sanitation, employee training, biofilm prevention, monitoring, and Legionella testing. She is expected to conclude that inadequately maintained recreational water facilities aboard the vessel were, more probably than not, the source of Luther’s infection.

The medical testimony will address both the severity of Luther’s illness and its likely origin. Infectious disease specialist Dr. Sean Liu is expected to testify that Luther suffered severe Legionella pneumophila pneumonia, which was a substantial medical cause of sepsis, acute hypoxic respiratory failure, prolonged hospitalization, an oxygen requirement, pleural effusion, and other complications.

Osinubi is also expected to testify that Luther’s infection was microbiologically confirmed and that he more likely than not acquired it aboard the Mardi Gras. Her opinions will address exposure to aerosolized water, the timing and mechanism of transmission, possible alternative sources of infection, and Luther’s medical susceptibility.

Carnival has denied the central allegations. In its answer, the company disputed that the Deck 16 tidal pool or whirlpools contained Legionella pneumophila and denied that Luther contracted the disease aboard the ship. Carnival maintains that it complied with applicable maintenance requirements and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s Vessel Sanitation Program and denies that its conduct caused Luther’s injuries.

LATEST NEWS
November 14, 2026
Pentair released its third-quarter results on Oct. 27, reporting an 18- percent decline in sales for its pool business compared with the same quarter ...
November 14, 2026
The Pool & Hot Tub Alliance (PHTA) is advancing revisions to four American National Standards covering water conservation, residential spas, and above...
November 14, 2026
The Southwest Pool & Spa Show will fill five days with education, networking, and industry events when it returns to San Antonio Tuesday through Satur...